You can sometimes use stump grindings as garden mulch, but choose the receiving bed before deciding to keep the pile. The useful question is how much suitable material that bed needs. If it can take only part of the pile, arrange a destination for the rest instead of making the mulch deeper just to use it up.
When planning stump grinding, tell the contractor you're considering reuse. Ask to look at the material and discuss where it would go before it gets spread. Grindings can contain substantial soil as well as wood, and the mixture may be quite different from the mulch you normally buy.
Check what you're proposing to spread
Look at a small accessible portion once the crew says the area is safe. Is it mostly woody material, or a dense mixture of dirt and fine particles? Are there stones, pieces of old landscape fabric or other debris? Don't put your hands into an unknown pile or try to sort suspected sharp or contaminated material yourself. Ask the contractor to assess material you can't confidently identify.
Also consider the tree's history. If disease, chemical contamination or an unknown prior treatment is a concern, get advice about that material before moving it to other plants. A general recommendation to recycle wood isn't an assessment of every stump or everything buried beside it.
LSU AgCenter specifically discusses reusing stump grindings as mulch. Its answer recommends a woody mulch layer around two inches deep, no more than three, in a shrub bed away from the base of the house. That guidance is for a surface layer of wood chips; it doesn't turn soil-heavy grindings into prepared planting soil. Keep the two jobs separate: choose material for the surface of an existing bed, and have the soil assessed for any new planting.
Start with one bed that actually needs mulch
Walk the bed and measure the existing mulch so you don't add another full layer where only a top-up is needed. If the bed already has enough mulch, keep it out of the receiving area calculation. Keep plant stems, tree trunks, drains and service points clear. University of Minnesota Extension's mulching guidance explains surface application and keeping mulch away from trunks and stems; plant and site conditions still matter when choosing the material and depth.
To estimate how much to keep, measure the bed area that needs topping up, excluding places you're keeping clear. Multiply that area in square feet by the proposed added depth in inches, then divide by 12 to estimate cubic feet.
For example, suppose a 100-square-foot bed already has one inch of suitable mulch and you're bringing it up to an agreed two-inch layer. You'd add one inch, so the calculation is 100 times 1 divided by 12, or about 8.3 cubic feet. Use the depth you're adding, not the full finished depth. These are example measurements, not a depth recommendation for every bed. If you're unsure whether the existing layer or the new material is suitable, have the landscaper check it before spreading.
That small calculation can change the hauling decision. If your measured receiving area needs much less than the pile, keeping everything means storing material or finding another appropriate use. You can ask to retain a defined portion and price removal of the balance. Check whether moving and spreading are included; leaving a pile beside the stump is a different service.
Keep the stump hole as a separate decision
Don't treat “keep the mulch” as an instruction to leave the future planting or lawn area full of woody material. Our guide to the finish after grinding explains why the next use needs its own preparation. Write down both destinations: what stays in the receiving bed and what condition the stump area needs afterward.
Show D&R the receiving bed as well as the stump when requesting work in our evaluated service area. With the material, usable space and handling agreed together, reuse becomes a practical part of the job rather than another pile you have to solve later.